Earnings vs. Multiple: 34 Years of S&P Returns
In any given year, how much of the S&P 500’s move came from earnings and how much from the multiple? We split all 34 years, 1992 to 2025. It swings from 13% to 94%.
Free Excel workbook. Price return only (dividends set aside).
Price equals earnings times the P/E, so every year’s S&P 500 move comes from earnings growth, a change in the multiple, or both. We split all 34 years from 1992 to 2025 to see which one did the work. The answer changes constantly, and in more than half the years the multiple won.
The multiple was the larger driver in 19 of 34 years (55.9%).
Its share of the year’s move ran from 12.9% (2025) to 93.6% (2002).
In 9 of 34 years, the multiple was 70% or more of the move.
In 13 of 34 years, earnings and the multiple pushed in opposite directions.
2002: EPS rose 2.0%, the P/E fell 24.8%, and the S&P fell 23.4%.
2020: forward EPS fell 6.1% and the S&P rose 16.3%. 2018: forward EPS rose 17.3% and the S&P fell 6.2%.
Over all 34 years, the multiple explains 70.7% of the variance in annual price returns.
Since 2011, the multiple has been the larger driver in 11 of 15 years.
Methodology: Price equals EPS times P/E, so each year’s log price change splits exactly into the log change in forward EPS and the log change in the P/E. S&P 500 price and forward 12-month consensus EPS from FactSet from 1999, with I/B/E/S forward estimates scaled to FactSet before that. Calendar years, price return only (dividends set aside).
Get the free workbook
See the split for every year in Excel.